Nuprl Lemma : bag-lub-comm
∀[T:Type]. ∀[eq:EqDecider(T)]. ∀[as,bs:bag(T)].  (bag-lub(eq;as;bs) = bag-lub(eq;bs;as) ∈ bag(T))
Proof
Definitions occuring in Statement : 
bag-lub: bag-lub(eq;b1;b2)
, 
bag: bag(T)
, 
deq: EqDecider(T)
, 
uall: ∀[x:A]. B[x]
, 
universe: Type
, 
equal: s = t ∈ T
Definitions unfolded in proof : 
uall: ∀[x:A]. B[x]
, 
member: t ∈ T
, 
bag-lub: bag-lub(eq;b1;b2)
, 
squash: ↓T
, 
prop: ℙ
, 
true: True
, 
subtype_rel: A ⊆r B
, 
uimplies: b supposing a
, 
guard: {T}
, 
iff: P 
⇐⇒ Q
, 
and: P ∧ Q
, 
rev_implies: P 
⇐ Q
, 
implies: P 
⇒ Q
, 
nat: ℕ
, 
label: ...$L... t
, 
all: ∀x:A. B[x]
, 
decidable: Dec(P)
, 
or: P ∨ Q
, 
satisfiable_int_formula: satisfiable_int_formula(fmla)
, 
exists: ∃x:A. B[x]
, 
false: False
, 
not: ¬A
, 
top: Top
, 
ge: i ≥ j 
, 
so_lambda: λ2x.t[x]
, 
so_apply: x[s]
Lemmas referenced : 
equal_wf, 
squash_wf, 
true_wf, 
bag-to-set_wf, 
bag-append-comm, 
bag-append_wf, 
iff_weakening_equal, 
bag-rep_wf, 
nat_wf, 
imax_com, 
bag-count_wf, 
decidable__equal_int, 
satisfiable-full-omega-tt, 
intformand_wf, 
intformnot_wf, 
intformeq_wf, 
itermVar_wf, 
int_formula_prop_and_lemma, 
int_formula_prop_not_lemma, 
int_formula_prop_eq_lemma, 
int_term_value_var_lemma, 
int_formula_prop_wf, 
imax_nat, 
nat_properties, 
decidable__le, 
intformle_wf, 
itermConstant_wf, 
int_formula_prop_le_lemma, 
int_term_value_constant_lemma, 
le_wf, 
list-subtype-bag, 
imax_wf, 
bag-combine_wf, 
bag_wf
Rules used in proof : 
sqequalSubstitution, 
sqequalTransitivity, 
computationStep, 
sqequalReflexivity, 
isect_memberFormation, 
introduction, 
cut, 
hypothesis, 
because_Cache, 
sqequalRule, 
sqequalHypSubstitution, 
isect_memberEquality, 
isectElimination, 
thin, 
hypothesisEquality, 
axiomEquality, 
applyEquality, 
lambdaEquality, 
imageElimination, 
extract_by_obid, 
equalityTransitivity, 
equalitySymmetry, 
natural_numberEquality, 
imageMemberEquality, 
baseClosed, 
cumulativity, 
universeEquality, 
independent_isectElimination, 
productElimination, 
independent_functionElimination, 
setElimination, 
rename, 
dependent_functionElimination, 
unionElimination, 
dependent_pairFormation, 
int_eqEquality, 
intEquality, 
voidElimination, 
voidEquality, 
independent_pairFormation, 
computeAll, 
dependent_set_memberEquality, 
lambdaFormation, 
applyLambdaEquality, 
functionEquality
Latex:
\mforall{}[T:Type].  \mforall{}[eq:EqDecider(T)].  \mforall{}[as,bs:bag(T)].    (bag-lub(eq;as;bs)  =  bag-lub(eq;bs;as))
Date html generated:
2018_05_21-PM-09_52_19
Last ObjectModification:
2017_07_26-PM-06_31_48
Theory : bags_2
Home
Index