{ es:event_system{i:l}. T:Type. leaders,failset:Id List. tg1a:Id.
  X,Y:Temporary AbsInterface(es;T).
    (Paxos-spec10(es;T;leaders;failset;tg1a;X;Y)
     Paxos-spec9(es;T;leaders;failset;tg1a;X;Y)) }

{ Proof }



Definitions occuring in Statement :  Paxos-spec10: Paxos-spec10(es;T;leaders;failset;tg1a;Decide;Input) Paxos-spec9: Paxos-spec9(es;T;leaders;failset;tg1a;Decide;Input) es-interface: Temporary AbsInterface(es;A) Id: Id all: x:A. B[x] implies: P  Q list: type List universe: Type
Definitions :  member: t  T Id: Id list: type List less_than: a < b no_repeats: no_repeats(T;l) le: A  B function: x:A  B[x] all: x:A. B[x] not: A es-filtered-propagate-iff1: Error :es-filtered-propagate-iff1,  l_all: (xL.P[x]) set: {x:A| B[x]}  nat_plus: event_ordering: EO universe: Type multiply: n * m length: ||as|| IdLnk: IdLnk es-collect-filter: Collect(size v's from X with maximum num[v] such that P[v]) pair: <a, b> lt_int: i <z j es-interface-pair-prior: X;Y eq_int: (i = j) mapfilter-class: (f[v] where v from X such that P[v]) isrcv: isrcv(k) assert: b Knd: Knd prop: l_member: (x  l) subtype_rel: A r B implies: P  Q and: P  Q atom: Atom$n false: False void: Void exists: x:A. B[x] surject: Surj(A;B;f) es-filtered-propagation: Error :es-filtered-propagation,  es-propagate-iff1: X  Y:T id-deq: IdDeq deq-member: deq-member(eq;x;L) filter: filter(P;l) es-valtype: Error :es-valtype,  es-kind: Error :es-kind,  es-E: E es-tag: Error :es-tag,  or: P  Q es-isrcv: Error :es-isrcv,  es-loc: loc(e) es-E-interface: E(X) lnk: lnk(k) lsrc: source(l) ldst: destination(l) eq_id: a = b band: p  q minus: -n imax: imax(a;b) es-interface-accum: es-interface-accum(f;x;X) es-prior-class-when: (X'?d) when Y spread: spread def map-class: (f[v] where v from X) es-tagged-true-class: Tagged_tt(X) accum-class: accum-class(a,x.f[a; x]; x.base[x]; X) nil: [] cons: [car / cdr] es-interface-at: X@i strong-subtype: strong-subtype(A;B) decide: case b of inl(x) =s[x] | inr(y) =t[y] fpf: a:A fp-B[a] subtype: S  T guard: {T} sum-map: f[x] for x  L sum: (f[x] | x < k) ge: i  j  b-union: A  B fset: fset(T) fpf-cap: f(x)?z fpf-sub: f  g es-vartype: Error :es-vartype,  es-state: Error :es-state,  deq: EqDecider(T) decl-state: Error :decl-state,  ma-state: State(ds) append: as @ bs rev_implies: P  Q iff: P  Q so_lambda: x.t[x] map: map(f;as) hd: hd(l) last: last(L) remove-repeats: remove-repeats(eq;L) select: l[i] class-program: ClassProgram(T) apply: f a so_apply: x[s] locl: locl(a) tl: tl(l) top: Top btrue: tt true: True sq_type: SQType(T) isl: isl(x) list-index: list-index(d;L;x) int_seg: {i..j} es-parameter-class: Parameter(p;X) es-interface-union: X+Y paxos-new-ballot: paxos-new-ballot(n; np_or_2b_or_firstballot; d; prevb) es-rec-combined-interface1-1: (f)(X,(Y)',self') intensional-universe: IType isect: x:A. B[x] real: rationals: lelt: i  j < k es-le: e loc e'  alle-lt: e<e'.P[e] es-locl: (e <loc e') so_lambda: so_lambda(x,y,z.t[x; y; z]) round-robin: round-robin(L) let: let Paxos-spec9-body: Paxos-spec9-body(es;T;f;acceptors;leaders;Input;Decide;...;...;...;...;...;...) Paxos-spec10-body: Paxos-spec10-body(es;T;f;acceptors;leaders;Input;Decide;...;...;...;...;...;...) Paxos-spec9: Paxos-spec9(es;T;leaders;failset;tg1a;Decide;Input) Paxos-spec10: Paxos-spec10(es;T;leaders;failset;tg1a;Decide;Input) MaAuto: Error :MaAuto,  D: Error :D,  CollapseTHENA: Error :CollapseTHENA,  it: inr: inr x  inl: inl x  le_int: i z j ifthenelse: if b then t else f fi  spreadn: spread3 lambda: x.A[x] es-filter-image: f[X] nat: es-interface: Temporary AbsInterface(es;A) equal: s = t CollapseTHEN: Error :CollapseTHEN,  pi2: snd(t) pi1: fst(t) natural_number: $n add: n + m es-collect-opt-max: es-collect-opt-max int: product: x:A  B[x] links-from-to: links(tg) from srclocs to dstlocs rcvs-on: Rcvs(tg) on links es-in-ports: Error :es-in-ports,  bool: unit: Unit union: left + right Try: Error :Try,  ExRepD: Error :ExRepD,  RepUR: Error :RepUR,  Auto: Error :Auto,  Unfold: Error :Unfold,  tactic: Error :tactic,  es-fwd-propagation-via: f:X  Y:T bfalse: ff es-interface-val: val(X,e) cand: A c B es-is-interface: (e in X) cless: Error :cless,  es-causl: (e < e') rel_plus: R^+ limited-type: LimitedType sqequal: s ~ t tagof: tag(k) es-first-at: e is first@ i s.t.  e.P[e] can-apply: can-apply(f;x) outl: outl(x) es-prior-val: (X)' bnot: b do-apply: do-apply(f;x) eq_bool: p =b q eq_atom: x =a y null: null(as) set_blt: Error :set_blt,  infix_ap: x f y grp_blt: Error :grp_blt,  b-exists: (i<n.P[i])_b bl-exists: (xL.P[x])_b bl-all: (xL.P[x])_b dcdr-to-bool: [d] eq_type: eq_type(T;T') eq_atom: eq_atom$n(x;y) q_le: q_le(r;s) q_less: q_less(a;b) qeq: qeq(r;s) deq-all-disjoint: deq-all-disjoint(eq;ass;bs) deq-disjoint: deq-disjoint(eq;as;bs) eq_lnk: a = b eq_pcl_term: Error :eq_pcl_term,  eq_pcl_basic: Error :eq_pcl_basic,  pcl-key-contains: Error :pcl-key-contains,  eq_pcl_key: Error :eq_pcl_key,  es-eq-E: e = e' bimplies: p  q bor: p q squash: T eq_knd: a = b fpf-dom: x  dom(f) grp_car: Error :grp_car,  token: "$token" atom: Atom es-prior-interface: prior(X) p-conditional: [f?g] p-outcome: Outcome eqof: eqof(d) es-first: first(e) lnk-inv: lnk-inv(l) es-init: es-init(es;e) es-first-from: Error :es-first-from,  es-lc: Error :es-lc,  last-change: Error :last-change,  list_ind: rec-case(a) of [] =s | x::y =z.t[x; y; z] so_lambda: x y.t[x; y] es-interface-part: (X|g=i) es-empty-interface: Empty imax-class: (maximum f[v]  lb with v from X) decidable: Dec(P) divides: b | a assoced: a ~ b set_leq: Error :set_leq,  set_lt: Error :set_lt,  grp_lt: Error :grp_lt,  l_exists: (xL. P[x]) l_contains: A  B inject: Inj(A;B;f) reducible: reducible(a) prime: prime(a) l_disjoint: l_disjoint(T;l1;l2) fun-connected: y is f*(x) qle: r  s qless: r < s q-rel: q-rel(r;x) fset-member: a  s f-subset: xs  ys fset-closed: (s closed under fs) cs-not-completed: in state s, a has not completed inning i cs-archived: by state s, a archived v in inning i cs-passed: by state s, a passed inning i without archiving a value cs-inning-committed: in state s, inning i has committed v cs-inning-committable: in state s, inning i could commit v  cs-archive-blocked: in state s, ws' blocks ws from archiving v in inning i cs-precondition: state s may consider v in inning i es-causle: e c e' existse-before: e<e'.P[e] existse-le: ee'.P[e] alle-le: ee'.P[e] alle-between1: e[e1,e2).P[e] existse-between1: e[e1,e2).P[e] alle-between2: e[e1,e2].P[e] existse-between2: e[e1,e2].P[e] existse-between3: e(e1,e2].P[e] collect-event: collect-event(es;X;n;v.num[v];L.P[L];e) es-fset-loc: i  locs(s) cut-order: a (X;f) b path-goes-thru: x-f*-y thru i ses-action: Action(e) ses-legal-sequence: Legal(pas) given prvt es-r-immediate-pred: es-r-immediate-pred(es;R;e';e) same-thread: same-thread(es;p;e;e') snd-it: Error :snd-it,  rcv-it: Error :rcv-it,  f2f+-pred: Error :f2f+-pred,  sq_stable: SqStable(P) uni_sat: a = !x:T. Q[x] inv_funs: InvFuns(A;B;f;g) eqfun_p: IsEqFun(T;eq) refl: Refl(T;x,y.E[x; y]) sym: Sym(T;x,y.E[x; y]) trans: Trans(T;x,y.E[x; y]) anti_sym: AntiSym(T;x,y.R[x; y]) connex: Connex(T;x,y.R[x; y]) coprime: CoPrime(a,b) ident: Error :ident,  assoc: Error :assoc,  comm: Error :comm,  inverse: Error :inverse,  bilinear: Error :bilinear,  bilinear_p: Error :bilinear_p,  action_p: Error :action_p,  dist_1op_2op_lr: Error :dist_1op_2op_lr,  fun_thru_1op: Error :fun_thru_1op,  fun_thru_2op: Error :fun_thru_2op,  cancel: Error :cancel,  monot: Error :monot,  monoid_p: Error :monoid_p,  group_p: Error :group_p,  monoid_hom_p: Error :monoid_hom_p,  grp_leq: Error :grp_leq,  integ_dom_p: Error :integ_dom_p,  prime_ideal_p: Error :prime_ideal_p,  is_list_splitting: is_list_splitting(T;L;LL;L2;f) is_accum_splitting: is_accum_splitting(T;A;L;LL;L2;f;g;x) req: x = y rnonneg: rnonneg(r) rleq: x  y i-member: r  I partitions: partitions(I;p) subtract: n - m strongwellfounded: SWellFounded(R[x; y]) es-local-pred: last(P) alle-between3: e(e1,e2].P[e] es-change-to: Error :es-change-to,  es-pred: pred(e) THENM: Error :THENM,  Complete: Error :Complete
Lemmas :  prior-val-val pair_eta_rw prior-val-unique es-prior-interface-locl decidable__es-locl is-prior-interface prior-val-induction3 es-prior-interface_wf0 btrue_neq_bfalse not_assert_elim es-causl_weakening es-locl_transitivity1 es-le_weakening es-causl-swellfnd ge_wf es-causl_wf is-prior-val sq_stable_from_decidable decidable__assert es-E-interface-property member-interface-at round-robin-equal round-robin-list-index prior-val-induction2 assert-eq-id Error :es-isrcv-loc,  Id_sq es-loc-pred nat_sq btrue_wf decide_wf int_sq es-prior-interface_wf it_wf rec-combined-interface1-1-val isl-list-index squash_wf parameter-class-val is-parameter-class not_functionality_wrt_iff assert_of_eq_int eq_int_wf eqtt_to_assert iff_transitivity eqff_to_assert assert_of_bnot bnot_wf outl_wf true_wf is-rec-combined-interface1-1 isl_wf es-prior-val_wf es-is-filter-image is-collect-opt-max guard_wf Error :is-in-ports,  member-rcvs-on false_wf round-robin_wf es-interface-subtype_rel es-interface-val_wf es-interface-val_wf2 bfalse_wf es-is-interface_wf es-loc_wf es-fwd-propagation-via_wf surject_wf Knd_sq Paxos-spec9_wf Paxos-spec10_wf event_ordering_wf Paxos-spec9-body_wf nat_plus_inc no_repeats_wf Error :es-filtered-propagate-iff1_wf,  es-collect-opt-max_wf pi1_wf pi2_wf unit_wf nat_plus_properties es-filter-image_wf ifthenelse_wf le_int_wf nat_properties es-locl_wf not_wf alle-lt_wf es-le_wf es-E-interface_wf l_all_wf l_all_wf2 es-interface_wf es-interface-top intensional-universe_wf es-propagate-iff1_wf es-interface-at_wf es-rec-combined-interface1-1_wf paxos-new-ballot_wf es-interface-union_wf bool_wf es-parameter-class_wf int_seg_wf length_wf1 list-index_wf id-deq_wf Id_wf lsrc_wf lnk_wf bool_sq assert_elim top_wf Error :es-in-ports_wf,  member_singleton iff_wf rev_implies_wf assert-eq-knd l_member-settype l_member_subtype length_wf_nat nat_wf le_wf member_wf Error :es-valtype_wf,  subtype_rel_wf Error :es-kind_wf,  es-E_wf l_member_wf Knd_wf assert_wf isrcv_wf rcvs-on_wf links-from-to_wf

\mforall{}es:event\_system\{i:l\}.  \mforall{}T:Type.  \mforall{}leaders,failset:Id  List.  \mforall{}tg1a:Id.
\mforall{}X,Y:Temporary  AbsInterface(es;T).
    (Paxos-spec10(es;T;leaders;failset;tg1a;X;Y)  {}\mRightarrow{}  Paxos-spec9(es;T;leaders;failset;tg1a;X;Y))


Date html generated: 2010_08_28-PM-01_59_47
Last ObjectModification: 2010_07_15-PM-02_28_38

Home Index